**”Forex Cashback vs. Rebates: Understanding the Key Differences and Benefits in 2024″**

In the fast-paced world of currency trading, every pip saved can translate into greater profitability—and that’s where forex cashback vs rebates programs come into play. Whether you’re a retail trader scalping the EUR/USD spread or an institution executing high-volume orders, understanding these incentives could unlock hidden savings in 2024. Cashback offers instant refunds per trade, while rebates reward cumulative volume, but which one aligns with your strategy? This guide breaks down their mechanics, benefits, and pitfalls, helping you navigate the evolving landscape of broker incentives. By the end, you’ll know exactly how to leverage these programs to cut costs and boost your trading edge.

1. Fundamental Definitions and Mechanisms

To navigate the world of forex trading efficiently, traders must understand the financial incentives available to them, particularly forex cashback vs rebates. While both mechanisms offer monetary benefits, they operate differently in terms of structure, eligibility, and payout mechanisms. This section provides a detailed breakdown of their fundamental definitions, operational mechanisms, and practical implications for traders in 2024.

1.1 What is Forex Cashback?

Forex cashback is a reward system where traders receive a percentage of their trading costs (spreads, commissions, or fees) back as a refund. This incentive is typically offered by brokers, affiliate programs, or third-party cashback providers to encourage trading activity.

Key Characteristics of Forex Cashback:

• Volume-Based Rewards: The amount refunded depends on the trader’s transaction volume. Higher trading volumes generally yield larger cashback amounts.
• Automatic or Manual Payouts: Some brokers credit cashback automatically to the trading account, while others require manual redemption.
• No Restrictions on Usage: Traders can withdraw cashback earnings or reinvest them into further trades.

### Example of Forex Cashback in Practice:
Suppose a broker offers 0.5 pips cashback per standard lot (100,000 units) traded. If a trader executes 10 standard lots with an average spread cost of 1 pip, they would receive:

• Total Spread Cost: 10 lots × 1 pip = 10 pips
• Cashback Earned: 10 lots × 0.5 pips = 5 pips
• Net Cost After Cashback: 10 pips – 5 pips = 5 pips

This effectively reduces trading costs by 50%, making cashback an attractive option for high-frequency traders.

1.2 What Are Forex Rebates?

Forex rebates are similar to cashback but are often structured as a fixed or variable refund per traded lot. They are commonly distributed through Introducing Brokers (IBs) or affiliate networks rather than directly from the broker.

Key Characteristics of Forex Rebates:

• Per-Lot Basis: Rebates are usually calculated per lot traded, regardless of spread or commission costs.
• Paid via Third Parties: Unlike cashback, rebates are frequently managed by IBs who share a portion of their commission with traders.
• Delayed Payouts: Rebates may be paid weekly, monthly, or upon reaching a minimum threshold.

### Example of Forex Rebates in Practice:
An IB offers $3 rebate per standard lot traded. If a trader executes 50 standard lots in a month:

• Total Rebate Earned: 50 lots × $3 = $150
• Payout: The $150 is credited to the trader’s account or external wallet at the end of the month.

Rebates are particularly beneficial for scalpers and day traders who execute numerous trades, as they provide consistent returns irrespective of profit or loss.

1.3 Comparing the Mechanisms: Forex Cashback vs Rebates

While both systems aim to reduce trading costs, their operational differences impact trader profitability differently.
| Feature | Forex Cashback | Forex Rebates |
|———————-|——————————————–|——————————————–|
| Calculation Basis | Percentage of spread/commission | Fixed or variable amount per lot |
| Payout Source | Directly from broker or cashback provider | Typically via Introducing Brokers (IBs) |
| Frequency | Instant or periodic (daily/weekly) | Often delayed (weekly/monthly) |
| Best For | Traders with high spread costs | High-volume traders (scalpers/day traders) |

Practical Insight:

• Cashback is more beneficial for traders dealing with brokers charging high spreads, as it directly offsets transaction costs.
• Rebates are more predictable, making them ideal for traders focusing on volume rather than spread reduction.

## 1.4 How Brokers and Affiliates Benefit from Cashback and Rebates
Brokers and IBs use these incentives to:

• Increase Trading Activity: Encourages traders to execute more trades.
• Enhance Client Retention: Traders are more likely to stick with brokers offering cost-saving mechanisms.
• Generate Referral Revenue: Affiliates earn commissions by promoting brokers with attractive rebate programs.

### Emerging Trends in 2024:

• Hybrid Models: Some brokers now combine cashback and rebates, offering tiered rewards based on trading volume.
• Blockchain-Based Payouts: A growing number of platforms are using cryptocurrencies for faster, transparent cashback/rebate distributions.

## Conclusion of Section 1
Understanding the fundamental differences between forex cashback vs rebates is crucial for traders looking to optimize their profitability. Cashback primarily reduces spread-related costs, while rebates provide fixed returns per lot traded. Depending on trading style and broker selection, one may be more advantageous than the other. In the next section, we will explore the eligibility criteria and payout structures in greater depth.
(Word Count: 750)
—

2. Key Differences: Cashback vs. Rebates

When trading forex, every pip saved or earned can significantly impact profitability. Two popular ways traders reduce costs and maximize returns are through forex cashback and rebates. While both offer monetary benefits, they operate differently in terms of structure, eligibility, and payout mechanisms. Understanding these differences is crucial for traders looking to optimize their strategies in 2024.
This section explores the key distinctions between forex cashback and rebates, helping traders determine which option aligns best with their trading style and financial goals.
—

1. Definition and Mechanism

Forex Cashback

Forex cashback is a reward system where traders receive a percentage of their trading costs (spreads, commissions, or fees) back as a monetary refund. Cashback is typically offered by:

• Broker-affiliated programs (direct from the broker)
• Third-party cashback providers (independent platforms that partner with brokers)

How It Works:

• Traders execute trades as usual.
• A portion of the trading cost is returned, either per trade or periodically (daily, weekly, monthly).
• Payouts can be in cash, brokerage credit, or even cryptocurrency.

Example:
A broker offers 0.5 pips cashback per lot traded. If a trader executes 10 standard lots (1,000,000 units) with a spread of 1 pip, they pay $100 in spread costs but receive $50 back as cashback.

Rebates (Forex Rebate Programs)

Rebates are similar to cashback but are usually tied to volume-based incentives and often require participation in a rebate program. Rebates are commonly offered through:

• Introducing Brokers (IBs)
• Affiliate networks
• Specialized rebate platforms

How It Works:

• Traders must register through a rebate provider.
• A fixed or variable rebate is paid per lot traded, regardless of profit or loss.
• Rebates are usually paid in cash, either to a trading account or external wallet.

Example:
A rebate program offers $3 per standard lot traded. If a trader executes 50 lots in a month, they receive $150 in rebates, irrespective of whether the trades were profitable.
—

2. Payment Structure and Frequency

Cashback: Proportional to Trading Costs

• Dynamic payout – Cashback is often a percentage of spreads/commissions, meaning higher trading costs result in larger refunds.
• Frequency – Can be instant, daily, or monthly, depending on the broker/provider.

### Rebates: Fixed or Volume-Based

• Fixed-rate payout – Traders earn a set amount per lot (e.g., $2 per standard lot).
• Tiered rebates – Some programs offer higher rebates for larger trading volumes.
• Frequency – Usually weekly or monthly.

Comparison Table:
| Feature | Forex Cashback | Forex Rebates |
|—————–|————–|————–|
| Payout Basis | Percentage of trading costs | Fixed amount per lot |
| Dependency | Spread/commission size | Trade volume |
| Flexibility | Varies with market conditions | Consistent regardless of spreads |
| Best For | High-frequency traders, scalpers | High-volume traders, position traders |
—

3. Eligibility and Accessibility

Cashback: Often Broker-Dependent

• Some brokers offer built-in cashback programs, while others require third-party services.
• May have minimum trade requirements (e.g., minimum lots per month).

### Rebates: Usually Third-Party Driven

• Typically accessed via IBs or affiliate programs.
• Traders must register through a rebate provider before trading to qualify.

Practical Insight:

• If a trader already has a preferred broker, they should check if it supports forex cashback vs rebates directly.
• Rebate programs may require switching brokers or opening a new account under an affiliate link.

—

4. Impact on Trading Strategy

Cashback Favors Certain Trading Styles

• Scalpers & High-Frequency Traders – Benefit more due to frequent trades and tighter spreads.
• Low-Spread Environments – Cashback is more valuable when trading costs are already minimal.

### Rebates Reward Volume Over Frequency

• Position Traders & Swing Traders – Can earn significant rebates by trading larger volumes, even with fewer trades.
• High-Lot Traders – Those trading standard or mini-lots consistently gain more from fixed rebates.

Case Study:

• Trader A (Scalper): Executes 200 trades/month with an average of 0.5 lots each. Cashback yields better returns due to high trade frequency.
• Trader B (Swing Trader): Executes 20 trades/month with 10 lots each. Rebates provide higher payouts due to larger volume.

—

5. Tax and Withdrawal Considerations

Cashback: Often Treated as a Refund

• May not be considered taxable income in some jurisdictions (varies by country).
• Usually credited back to the trading account or via PayPal/Skrill.

### Rebates: May Be Taxable

• Often classified as commission income or referral earnings.
• Traders should consult tax regulations in their region.

—

Conclusion: Which is Better for Forex Traders?

The choice between forex cashback vs rebates depends on:

• Trading volume → Rebates favor high-volume traders.
• Frequency of trades → Cashback benefits frequent traders.
• Broker flexibility → Rebates may require using specific brokers.

For optimal cost savings, some traders combine both—using cashback for frequent trades and rebates for high-volume positions.
In 2024, as forex brokers and third-party providers refine these programs, traders should compare offers and select the model that best enhances their profitability.
—
Next Section Preview: “3. Pros and Cons: Evaluating Forex Cashback and Rebates” – A deep dive into the advantages and limitations of each model.
By understanding these key differences, traders can make informed decisions and maximize their earnings in the competitive forex market.

3. Benefits for Different Trading Styles

When choosing between forex cashback vs rebates, traders must consider how each model aligns with their trading style. Different strategies—such as scalping, day trading, swing trading, and long-term investing—benefit uniquely from cashback and rebate programs. Understanding these distinctions can help traders maximize their profitability while minimizing costs.

1. Scalping: High-Frequency Trading Benefits

Scalpers execute dozens or even hundreds of trades per day, capitalizing on small price movements. Since transaction costs (spreads and commissions) significantly impact profitability, rebates are often the preferred choice for scalpers.

Why Rebates Work Best for Scalpers:

• Per-Trade Compensation: Rebates provide a fixed or variable refund per trade, directly offsetting commission costs.
• Lower Net Trading Costs: Since scalpers trade frequently, even small rebates per trade accumulate into substantial savings.
• Tighter Spreads: Some brokers offer rebates in exchange for slightly wider spreads, but scalpers often prioritize execution speed over spread size.

Example: A scalper executes 200 trades daily with a $0.50 rebate per lot. This results in $100 daily savings, significantly improving net profitability.
Cashback Limitations for Scalpers:

• Cashback is typically calculated as a percentage of spreads, which may not compensate enough for high-volume traders.
• Delayed payouts (monthly or quarterly) reduce immediate liquidity benefits.

## 2. Day Trading: Balancing Speed and Cost Efficiency
Day traders hold positions for hours but close all trades before the market closes. They benefit from both forex cashback and rebates, depending on their broker’s fee structure.

Optimal Choice: Hybrid Approach

• Rebates for Commission-Based Brokers: If a day trader uses an ECN/STP broker with commissions, rebates directly reduce per-trade costs.
• Cashback for Spread-Based Brokers: If trading with a market maker or spread-focused broker, cashback (a percentage of the spread) provides better value.

Example:

• A day trader using an ECN broker pays $3.50 per lot in commissions but receives a $2 rebate, effectively reducing costs to $1.50 per lot.
• Alternatively, a trader on a spread-based broker with 1.2 pips average spread and 0.3 pip cashback earns $3 per standard lot traded.

Key Consideration:
Day traders should analyze their broker’s fee model to determine whether forex cashback vs rebates provides better savings.

3. Swing Trading: Medium-Term Cost Reduction

Swing traders hold positions for days or weeks, trading less frequently than scalpers or day traders. Since they don’t generate as many trades, cashback often becomes more beneficial.

Why Cashback Suits Swing Traders:

• Higher Spreads, Higher Rewards: Swing traders often deal with wider spreads (overnight swaps, weekend gaps), making cashback more lucrative.
• Percentage-Based Returns: Since swing trades involve larger position sizes, cashback as a percentage of spreads yields meaningful returns.
• Less Dependency on Rebate Volume: Fewer trades mean per-trade rebates have less impact compared to cashback.

Example:
A swing trader places 20 standard lots monthly with an average spread of 1.5 pips. With a 0.5 pip cashback, they earn $10 per lot, totaling $200 monthly.
Rebate Drawbacks for Swing Traders:

• Since rebates are volume-dependent, swing traders may not generate enough trades to justify a rebate-focused account.

## 4. Long-Term Investors: Passive Earnings with Cashback
Position traders and investors hold trades for months or years, prioritizing macroeconomic trends over short-term price fluctuations. For them, cashback is the clear winner.

Advantages of Cashback for Long-Term Traders:

• Accumulated Over Time: Even small cashback percentages compound over months, providing passive income.
• No Need for High Trade Frequency: Unlike rebates, cashback doesn’t require frequent trading to be valuable.
• Hedging Benefits: Some brokers allow cashback on both sides of a hedged position, increasing profitability.

Example:
A long-term trader opens a 10-lot EUR/USD position with a 2-pip spread. A 0.4-pip cashback returns $40 per trade, regardless of how long the position stays open.
Why Rebates Are Less Effective:

• Long-term traders execute fewer trades, making per-trade rebates negligible.

## Conclusion: Matching Forex Cashback vs Rebates to Your Strategy
Choosing between forex cashback vs rebates depends largely on trading frequency, broker type, and cost structure:
| Trading Style | Best Option | Key Reason |
|——————|—————-|—————-|
| Scalping | Rebates | High trade volume maximizes per-trade refunds |
| Day Trading | Rebates or Hybrid | Depends on commission vs. spread-based broker |
| Swing Trading | Cashback | Benefits from percentage-based spread returns |
| Long-Term Investing | Cashback | Earns passive income without frequent trading |
By aligning cashback or rebates with their trading style, forex traders can optimize cost efficiency and enhance overall profitability in 2024.

4. How to Choose in 2024

When deciding between forex cashback vs rebates, traders must carefully evaluate their trading style, frequency, and financial objectives. Both cashback and rebate programs offer monetary benefits, but their structures, payout mechanisms, and suitability vary. This section provides a detailed guide on selecting the right option in 2024, ensuring you maximize your trading profits efficiently.

1. Assess Your Trading Volume and Frequency

One of the most critical factors in choosing between forex cashback and rebates is your trading volume.

• High-Volume Traders: If you execute numerous trades daily or weekly, rebate programs may be more advantageous. Rebates typically offer a fixed amount per lot traded, meaning the more you trade, the higher your earnings. For example, if a broker offers a $5 rebate per standard lot (100,000 units), a trader executing 50 lots per month earns $250 in rebates.
• Low to Moderate-Volume Traders: If your trading activity is sporadic or involves fewer transactions, forex cashback might be more beneficial. Cashback is often a percentage of the spread or commission (e.g., 0.5–1 pip per trade), making it more flexible for traders who don’t trade in high volumes.

### Practical Example:

• Rebate Scenario: A scalper trading 10 standard lots daily at $3 rebate per lot earns ~$600/month.
• Cashback Scenario: A swing trader making 20 trades monthly with an average cashback of $2 per trade earns $40/month.

## 2. Consider Your Broker’s Fee Structure
The type of broker you use—ECN, STP, or Market Maker—affects whether cashback or rebates are more profitable.

• ECN/STP Brokers (Commission-Based): These brokers charge a fixed commission per trade. Cashback programs often return a portion of this commission, making them ideal for traders who prefer tight spreads but pay separate fees.
• Market Makers (Spread-Based): Since these brokers earn from wider spreads, rebates (paid per lot) may be more lucrative, as they directly offset trading costs.

### Key Insight:

• If your broker has high commissions, prioritize cashback.
• If spreads are wide but commissions low, rebates may be better.

## 3. Evaluate Payout Terms and Flexibility
Cashback and rebate programs differ in payout frequency and conditions.

• Cashback Payouts:

– Usually credited per trade or daily.
– Often withdrawable once a minimum threshold is met (e.g., $50).
– Some brokers offer cashback in real-time, enhancing liquidity.

• Rebate Payouts:

– Typically paid weekly or monthly.
– May require a minimum trading volume before withdrawal.
– Some rebate providers pay directly to a bank account, bypassing the broker.

Tip for 2024:

If you need immediate liquidity, opt for brokers offering instant cashback. If you prefer structured payouts, rebates with monthly settlements may be preferable.

4. Analyze Long-Term vs. Short-Term Benefits

Your trading horizon influences which program is more beneficial.

• Short-Term Traders (Scalpers/Day Traders):

– Rebates provide consistent per-lot returns, ideal for frequent trades.
– Example: A day trader generating 100+ trades monthly benefits more from fixed rebates.

• Long-Term Traders (Swing/Position Traders):

– Cashback is more useful since fewer, larger trades still yield returns.
– Example: A position trader holding trades for weeks benefits from cashback on wider spreads.

5. Check Broker and Program Reputation

Not all cashback and rebate providers are equal. In 2024, due diligence is essential.

• For Cashback:

– Verify if the broker has a transparent cashback policy.
– Avoid brokers that restrict withdrawals or impose hidden conditions.

• For Rebates:

– Use third-party rebate aggregators (e.g., CashbackForex, ForexRebates) for better rates.
– Ensure the rebate provider has a reliable payout history.

Red Flags to Watch:

• Delayed payments
• Unrealistically high rebate offers (could indicate a scam)
• Brokers with poor regulatory standing

## 6. Calculate Cost-Benefit for Your Strategy
To determine which program is more profitable, perform a simple cost-benefit analysis:
1. Estimate Monthly Trading Volume (e.g., 50 lots).
2. Compare Potential Earnings:
– Rebate: 50 lots × $3 = $150
– Cashback: 50 trades × $1.5 = $75
3. Subtract Trading Costs:
– If spreads/commissions are lower with one option, factor that in.

Final Decision-Making Tool:

• If rebates earn more after costs, choose them.
• If cashback provides better net returns, opt for it.

## Conclusion: Which Should You Choose in 2024?
The choice between forex cashback vs rebates depends on:
✔ Trading volume (high = rebates, low = cashback)
✔ Broker type (ECN = cashback, Market Maker = rebates)
✔ Payout preferences (instant vs. delayed)
✔ Strategy (scalping vs. long-term trading)
In 2024, traders should prioritize transparency, payout reliability, and alignment with their trading habits. By carefully evaluating these factors, you can optimize your forex trading profitability effectively.
—
This structured approach ensures traders make an informed decision between forex cashback and rebates, maximizing their earnings in 2024.

5. Risks and Pitfalls

When trading forex, cashback and rebate programs can significantly enhance profitability by reducing trading costs. However, traders must be aware of the risks and pitfalls associated with these incentives to avoid unexpected drawbacks. Understanding these challenges ensures that traders maximize benefits while mitigating potential downsides.
This section explores the key risks and pitfalls of forex cashback vs. rebates, providing practical insights to help traders make informed decisions.
—

1. Hidden Terms and Conditions

One of the most common pitfalls in both forex cashback and rebate programs is the presence of restrictive terms and conditions. Many brokers and cashback providers impose clauses that limit payouts or disqualify traders under certain circumstances.

Examples of Hidden Restrictions:

• Minimum Trading Volume Requirements – Some rebate programs require traders to execute a specific number of lots before becoming eligible.
• Withdrawal Limitations – Certain cashback providers may restrict withdrawals until a threshold is met.
• Exclusion of Certain Accounts – Rebates may not apply to ECN or Islamic accounts, reducing their usefulness for some traders.

### Mitigation Strategy:

• Always review the fine print before enrolling in a program.
• Compare multiple providers to find the most transparent terms.

—

2. Conflict of Interest with Brokers

Forex cashback and rebate programs often involve third-party affiliates who earn commissions from brokers. This can create a conflict of interest, where:

• Affiliates may promote high-rebate brokers that have poor execution or higher spreads.
• Cashback providers might favor brokers with higher commissions rather than those offering the best trading conditions.

### Example Scenario:
A trader chooses a broker solely because it offers high rebates, only to discover that the spreads are wider, negating the rebate benefits.

Mitigation Strategy:

• Prioritize brokers with strong regulatory oversight and tight spreads.
• Use independent broker reviews rather than relying solely on affiliate recommendations.

—

3. Impact on Trading Behavior

Cashback and rebates can psychologically influence traders to overtrade or take excessive risks. Since these incentives reward volume, traders may:

• Increase trade frequency to earn more cashback, leading to higher transaction costs.
• Hold losing positions longer to meet rebate thresholds, increasing potential losses.

### Example Scenario:
A trader executes 50 micro-lots in a day to maximize rebates, but poor trade selection results in net losses despite the rebate earnings.

Mitigation Strategy:

• Stick to a disciplined trading plan regardless of cashback incentives.
• Avoid altering position sizes solely to qualify for rebates.

—

4. Tax Implications

Many traders overlook the tax consequences of forex cashback and rebates. Depending on jurisdiction:

• Rebates may be considered taxable income, increasing tax liability.
• Cashback earnings might need reporting as miscellaneous income.

### Example Scenario:
A U.S.-based trader receives $2,000 in annual rebates but fails to report them, leading to penalties during an IRS audit.

Mitigation Strategy:

• Consult a tax professional to understand reporting requirements.
• Maintain records of all cashback and rebate earnings.

—

5. Broker Reliability and Payout Delays

Not all brokers and cashback providers process payments promptly. Common issues include:

• Delayed or withheld rebates due to “technical issues.”
• Sudden termination of cashback programs without notice.
• Brokers refusing withdrawals if cashback earnings are deemed excessive.

### Example Scenario:
A trader accumulates $500 in rebates, but the broker imposes arbitrary withdrawal restrictions, delaying access to funds.

Mitigation Strategy:

• Choose brokers with strong reputations and reliable payout histories.
• Monitor cashback provider reviews for red flags.

—

6. Overemphasis on Cost Savings vs. Profitability

While forex cashback vs. rebates can reduce trading costs, they should not be the sole focus. Traders may fall into the trap of:

• Neglecting strategy refinement in favor of chasing rebates.
• Underestimating slippage and execution quality in pursuit of higher cashback.

### Example Scenario:
A scalper selects a broker with high rebates but suffers from frequent requotes, reducing overall profitability.

Mitigation Strategy:

• Balance cost-saving incentives with execution quality.
• Test brokers in a demo account before committing real funds.

—

Conclusion

Forex cashback and rebate programs offer tangible benefits, but traders must navigate their risks carefully. Hidden terms, broker conflicts, psychological biases, tax implications, payout delays, and an overemphasis on savings can undermine profitability.
By understanding these pitfalls and implementing the mitigation strategies discussed, traders can leverage forex cashback vs. rebates effectively while maintaining a disciplined and profitable trading approach.
Always prioritize transparency, broker reliability, and long-term trading success over short-term rebate gains.

8 FAQs on Forex Cashback vs. Rebates (2024)

What is the main difference between forex cashback and rebates?

• Forex cashback provides instant, per-trade refunds (e.g., $0.50 per lot).
• Rebates are post-trade, volume-based payouts (e.g., 0.3 pips per trade).

Cashback suits scalpers, while rebates favor swing traders.

Which is better for high-frequency traders: forex cashback or rebates?

Forex cashback is typically superior for high-frequency traders because:

• Immediate payouts improve liquidity.
• Smaller, consistent returns compound over many trades.

Rebates may lag in payout timing, affecting cash flow.

How do forex cashback and rebates impact trading costs?

Both reduce net costs, but cashback directly offsets spreads/commissions, while rebates act as retroactive discounts. For example:

• A $7 commission with $2 cashback = $5 net cost.
• A $7 commission with a $3 rebate = $4 net cost (paid later).

Can I use both forex cashback and rebates simultaneously?

Some brokers offer hybrid programs, but most require choosing one. Overlap may violate terms—always check broker policies.

Are there hidden risks with forex cashback or rebates?

Yes, watch for:

• Broker restrictions (minimum volumes, withdrawal limits).
• Tax implications (cashback may be taxable income).
• Conflict with trading strategy (e.g., rebates discouraging quick exits).

How do I choose between cashback and rebates in 2024?

Consider:

• Trading volume: High volume = rebates; low volume = cashback.
• Payout timing: Need instant funds? Cashback wins.
• Broker reliability: Prioritize transparent, regulated providers.

Do forex cashback and rebates work with all account types?

Mostly yes, but:

• ECN accounts often qualify for rebates.
• Standard accounts may have cashback caps.

Always confirm with your broker.

Which offers higher long-term savings: forex cashback or rebates?

Rebates usually yield greater savings for large-volume traders (e.g., 0.5 pips per lot vs. fixed cashback). However, cashback provides predictable, short-term gains.